500,000 migrants needed: Treasury

This Is Lancashire: The Scottish Government indicated in its White Paper on independence that it plans to adopt different immigration policies to those of the UK The Scottish Government indicated in its White Paper on independence that it plans to adopt different immigration policies to those of the UK

Scotland needs almost 500,000 migrants over the next 20 years to achieve the same balance of pensioners and working-age adults as the UK, according to the Treasury.

The increase would be the equivalent of adding another Edinburgh to Scotland's population, the UK Government department said.

The ageing population and the implications on levels of migration is one of five key areas considered in the Treasury's latest analysis assessing an independent Scotland's fiscal position between 2016 - the first year of independence - and 2035/36.

Scotland's population is projected to age more rapidly in the future compared with the UK as a whole.

The Treasury has considered the levels of net annual migration which would be required in an independent Scotland in order for it to achieve a "dependency ratio" equivalent to that projected for the UK over the next two decades.

The dependency ratio is the number of people who are predominantly receiving from the state - pensioners - versus the number of people who are paying most of the taxes into the state - working-age adults.

Using Office for National Statistics data, the Treasury has calculated that Scotland would have to treble its rate of net annual migration under independence to match UK demographics.

As part of the UK, net annual migration to Scotland of 7,000 is assumed but this would have to increase to 24,000 under independence to achieve the same dependency ratio, it said.

"We assume that Scotland would have higher migration as an independent country than it would have within the UK, because that's what the Scottish Government have said and we want to take that into account, but you still see more of a demographic challenge," the Treasury said.

"To get the demographics simply to match the UK, Scotland would have to go up to the 'high migration scenario', which is 24,000 people a year net, so that's more than tripling in migration relative to Scotland within the UK.

"Over the 20-year period that we looked at that would basically be the equivalent of adding the population of Edinburgh to the Scottish population.

"So that would be a very substantial change in Scotland's demographics needed simply to keep this dependency ratio online.

"All of this challenge is simply smoothed away within the union and borne across the population as a whole."

The Scottish Government has already indicated in its White Paper on independence that it plans to adopt different immigration policies to those of the UK to meet Scotland's needs, including boosting its working-age population.

Scottish Conservative MSP Alex Johnstone said: "Migrant workers play a vital role in Scotland's economy and many of our successful businesses would not be able to cope without them.

"But under the SNP's hare-brained separation plans, we would need an open-door approach just to have a fighting chance of balancing the books.

"That would require a different immigration policy to the rest of the UK, which would without question mean border controls were an absolute necessity."

Scottish Labour's pensions spokesman Gregg McClymont said: "Pooling and sharing our resources across the whole of the UK means pensions are more affordable in Scotland. Only separation puts the pensions of Scots at risk.

"The nationalists tell us they will plug the pensions gap in a separate Scotland by increasing immigration but have failed to set out any plan."

General Register Office for Scotland figures show that between 2003/04 and 2010/11, Scotland saw net annual migration gains of at least 18,600 per year.

In 2010/11 the net migration gain was 30,200, however it fell to 12,700 in 2011/12.

A spokesman for Finance Secretary John Swinney said: "Net migration to Scotland is already more than 10,000 a year and independence will allow us to have a flexible policy to suit our economic needs, unlike UK immigration policy which is harming Scotland and which has just this week been condemned by one of Scotland's leading university principals as 'trying its best to destroy a global brand'.

"It is deeply revealing, but not surprising, that the Treasury's main attack on independence plays the immigration card, as the Westminster establishment panders to a Ukip agenda."

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

11:43am Sat 24 May 14

bmoc55 says...

Send our lot up to them and free up school places and reduce the pressures on our English NHS
Send our lot up to them and free up school places and reduce the pressures on our English NHS bmoc55
  • Score: 3

10:02pm Sat 24 May 14

cosmick says...

bmoc55 wrote:
Send our lot up to them and free up school places and reduce the pressures on our English NHS
Yes then make sure the vote to exit our little group and go it alone. Then sort out border control.
[quote][p][bold]bmoc55[/bold] wrote: Send our lot up to them and free up school places and reduce the pressures on our English NHS[/p][/quote]Yes then make sure the vote to exit our little group and go it alone. Then sort out border control. cosmick
  • Score: 1

12:31pm Sun 25 May 14

Chippy70 says...

They can have all of our lot south of the border and if all they need is 500,000 we can fulfill that in a couple of weeks.
They can have all of our lot south of the border and if all they need is 500,000 we can fulfill that in a couple of weeks. Chippy70
  • Score: 0
Post a comment

Remember you are personally responsible for what you post on this site and must abide by our site terms. Do not post anything that is false, abusive or malicious. If you wish to complain, please use the ‘report this post’ link.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree