Bury MP votes to keep 'bedroom tax'

This Is Lancashire: MP David Nuttall MP David Nuttall

THE MP for Bury North was the only person to vote against a Bill which aimed to scrap the “bedroom tax”.

David Nuttall voted against a bill put forward by Labour MP Ian Lavery, which called on the spare room subsidy, dubbed the ‘bedroom tax’ by critics, to be axed.

In a Commons vote on the Bill last Wednesday, 226 MPs voted for Mr Lavery’s 10-minute rule Bill —which gives an opportunity for MPs to speak for 10 minutes on any given issue in an attempt to introduce legislation — while just Mr Nuttall, pictured, opposed.

Mr Nuttall’s colleagues in the governing coalition parties abstained, and the backbenches of the Tory ranks were not well attended.

Although the Bill was approved, it is very unlikely to become law, as it has been allocated a limited amount of parliamentary time.

Speaking in the Commons, Mr Lavery said that his Bill sought to “restore justice for up to 660,000 people” across the country.

He said: “They have been inhumanely let down by the government’s reforms to housing benefit in the social sector.

“The tax has caused heartache and devastation to thousands of residents up and down this country.”

Under the policy, residents receive a 14 per cent reduction in housing benefit if they have a spare room, or a 25 per cent cut if they have two spare rooms.

Bury Council previously said that 2,513 people across the borough are affected by the policy.

After the debate, Mr Nuttall said: “This country has to start living within its means and this means taking tough and difficult decisions. As we have seen with a growing economy and more people in work able to provide for themselves and their families, the government’s economic plan is working.

“It is only by having a strong and growing economy that the nation will be able to afford to pay for our NHS, the police, our Armed Forces, our schools and all the other public services people rely on.

“Labour demonstrated today that they are the same old Labour who want to spend more on welfare and borrow more, leaving more debts for the next generation.”

Comments (4)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

4:39pm Fri 21 Feb 14

NICKI83 says...

I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW HOW HE CAN STATE THAT PEOPLE SHOULD LIVE TO THEIR MEANS WHEN A 2 BEDROOMED PRIVATE SECTOR RENT CAN BE MORE EXPENSIVE THAN A 3 BEDROOMED PUBLIC SECTOR RENT YET THEY ARE WILLING TO PAY THAT IT MAKES NO SENSE PENALISING PEOPLE FOR WANTING MORE SPACE THEY HAVENT INVESTIGATED WHY PEOPLE MIGHT NEED EXTRA ROOMS
I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW HOW HE CAN STATE THAT PEOPLE SHOULD LIVE TO THEIR MEANS WHEN A 2 BEDROOMED PRIVATE SECTOR RENT CAN BE MORE EXPENSIVE THAN A 3 BEDROOMED PUBLIC SECTOR RENT YET THEY ARE WILLING TO PAY THAT IT MAKES NO SENSE PENALISING PEOPLE FOR WANTING MORE SPACE THEY HAVENT INVESTIGATED WHY PEOPLE MIGHT NEED EXTRA ROOMS NICKI83
  • Score: 12

3:15pm Sat 22 Feb 14

Mr. Marcus says...

Typical Tory.
He does not know what life in the real world is.
Typical Tory. He does not know what life in the real world is. Mr. Marcus
  • Score: 7

11:52pm Sat 22 Feb 14

deafboy says...

He's just towing the party line. He's a coward and he's more concerned about keeping his job than anything else. He voted against having a debate on the use of foodbanks too. They are all towing the line in their own interests. They don't represent the general public at all but I'll bet if you offered a donation to the party he'd be willing to listen.
He's just towing the party line. He's a coward and he's more concerned about keeping his job than anything else. He voted against having a debate on the use of foodbanks too. They are all towing the line in their own interests. They don't represent the general public at all but I'll bet if you offered a donation to the party he'd be willing to listen. deafboy
  • Score: 7

12:29am Thu 27 Feb 14

KazzyJ says...

The Bedroom tax is nothing but a joke at the expense of ordinary people. It is causing havoc within all types of housing agencies and suffering to those in particularly difficult circumstance such as the long term severely disabled. This Government has no heart, only a **** for more power. They will carry on cutting this country to the bone til it bleeds out, and there won't be an NHS left to bandage it up.
The Bedroom tax is nothing but a joke at the expense of ordinary people. It is causing havoc within all types of housing agencies and suffering to those in particularly difficult circumstance such as the long term severely disabled. This Government has no heart, only a **** for more power. They will carry on cutting this country to the bone til it bleeds out, and there won't be an NHS left to bandage it up. KazzyJ
  • Score: 6

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree